American Christianity has entered a strange moment: millions of believers—especially younger ones—are being discipled more by TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube than by Scripture or their local church. The result is a generation shaped not by pastors, doctrine, or real accountability, but by algorithms. This is a spiritual crisis.
Influencers Aren’t Pastors — They’re Performers
Influencers rise to the top because they’re charismatic, provocative, and emotionally compelling. None of those traits qualify someone to teach the Word of God. Yet many Christians trust online personalities more than the pastors who actually shepherd their souls.
A pastor carries responsibility.
An influencer carries a ring light.
One answers to God for his teaching.
The other answers to engagement metrics.
The Algorithm Has Become a Pulpit
Most viral “Christian” content exists for one reason: it performs well. Dramatic “prophecies,” hot takes on church scandals, emotional testimonies, deconstruction journeys—these dominate feeds not because they’re sound, but because they’re addictive.
This makes the algorithm a type of digital catechism.
But the algorithm does not love you.
And it certainly doesn’t care about biblical truth.
Influencer Discipleship Breeds Shallow Faith
When Christians learn theology through memes and one-minute videos, they become:
- suspicious of the church
- emotionally driven instead of biblically grounded
- dependent on personalities
- resistant to correction
- easy prey for false teaching
It is impossible to grow deep roots in shallow soil.
The Local Church Is God’s Design
Scripture gives spiritual authority to biblically qualified elders in real, embodied communities—not internet celebrities with no oversight. The Christian life requires sacraments, discipline, fellowship, teaching, and accountability.
You cannot be pastored through a For You page.
Discernment Is the Urgent Need
Online voices can be helpful. Some are faithful. But Christians must distinguish between content and discipleship, charisma and calling, entertainment and truth.
If you listen to an influencer more than your pastor, your spiritual diet is being curated by a platform—not by God’s Word.
The Church Doesn’t Need More Influencers. It Needs Stronger Disciples.
Digital content may inspire you. It may challenge you. But it cannot replace the church Christ established or the shepherds He appointed.
Influencers can offer opinions.
Only pastors can shepherd souls.
The algorithm is not your pastor.
And it never will be.
Notice: This column is printed with permission. Opinion pieces published by AFN.net are the sole responsibility of the article's author(s), or of the person(s) or organization(s) quoted therein, and do not necessarily represent those of the staff or management of, or advertisers who support the American Family News Network, AFN.net, our parent organization or its other affiliates.
